The After Show Treatment For Sensitive Skin
The After Show Treatment For Sensitive Skin
Product Description
A fragrance-free, gel-to-oil first cleanser from Jordan Samuel Skin, reformulated from the original After Show without fruit acids or fragrance to gently melt away makeup, SPF and stage-grade grime on sensitive and sensitized skin. A blend of olive, jojoba and grape seed oils lifts impurities, while green tea, aloe and chamomile soothe and hydrate so skin is left soft, calm and never stripped.
β¨ Texture & Feel
Lifts Even Stage Makeup
Created by former dancer Jordan Samuel to dissolve heavy performance makeup and SPF without scrubbing or stripping.
Soothing Botanical Blend
Green tea, aloe, chamomile and calendula calm irritation and help keep redness and reactivity at bay.
No Fragrance, No Fruit Acids
Reformulated from the original After Show specifically for sensitive and sensitized complexions.
Vegan & Leaping Bunny Approved
Made in the USA, never tested on animals, and free from parabens, sulfates and silicones.
π‘οΈ Safety & Compatibility
No retinoids, salicylic acid, hydroquinone or chemical UV filters. Generally considered low-risk, but confirm with your doctor.
Fragrance-free and EU-allergen-free, built around soothing extracts. Patch test still advised for very reactive skin.
Contains olive, jojoba and grape seed oils plus sucrose laurate, which can feed Malassezia. Rinse-off use lowers but does not remove the risk.
As a first-step rinse-off cleanser it washes away before serums, so it layers fine ahead of retinol, vitamin C, AHA or BHA.
Gentle enough to melt eye makeup, but avoid getting it directly in the eyes and rinse thoroughly.
Caprylic/Capric Triglyceride is coconut-sourced; those with severe coconut sensitivities should patch test first.
π¬ Ingredient Breakdown
π₯₯ Caprylic/Capric Triglyceride 1st on INCI Proven
The lightweight base of the formula. A coconut-derived emollient (MCT) that gives the cleanser its silky slip and helps dissolve makeup without leaving a heavy film.
- Stability: Highly resistant to oxidation, so it resists going rancid and supports a long shelf life.
- Note: The problematic lauric acid is stripped out, leaving caprylic and capric acids that actually trend antifungal.
π« Olea Europaea (Olive) Fruit Oil 2nd on INCI Proven
A nourishing, oleic-acid-rich oil used for centuries to soften skin and break down makeup and SPF. It brings antioxidants and squalene to the blend.
- Composition: Mainly oleic acid, which supports skin conditioning and helps lift oil-based grime.
- Comedogenic: Rates around 2-3 on its own, so overall formulation and rinse-off use matter for acne-prone skin.
π΅ Camellia Sinensis (Green Tea) Leaf Extract Soothing Proven
One of the most researched botanical extracts in skincare. Antioxidant catechins help calm and protect stressed, sensitized skin.
- Antioxidant: EGCG and other catechins help neutralize free radicals and reduce visible redness.
- Soothing: Studies link green tea to reduced irritation and inflammation on the skin.
πΏ Aloe Barbadensis Leaf Juice Soothing Proven
A classic calming, hydrating ingredient that helps soothe an irritated or sensitive complexion and binds moisture to the skin.
- Benefits: Anti-inflammatory and moisturizing, carrying vitamins A, C and E plus skin-friendly sugars.
πΌ Chamomile & Calendula Extracts Calming Duo Promising
Roman chamomile (Anthemis Nobilis) and marigold (Calendula Officinalis) flower extracts work together to help keep inflammation and sensitivity in check.
- Calendula: Contains flavonoids with antioxidant and anti-inflammatory properties.
- Chamomile: Long used to soothe and comfort reactive skin.
π± Jojoba & Grape Seed Oils Emollients Proven
Simmondsia Chinensis (jojoba) closely mirrors skin's own sebum, while Vitis Vinifera (grape seed) adds antioxidants. Together they condition and reinforce the barrier as they cleanse.
- Jojoba: Made of wax esters that reduce water loss and support barrier recovery.
- Grape Seed: Rich in vitamin E and polyphenols with emollient, soothing benefits.
π‘οΈ Tocopheryl Acetate (Vitamin E) + Glycerin Support Proven
Vitamin E is a stable antioxidant that protects skin from free radicals, while glycerin is a powerhouse humectant that pulls water into the upper layers to leave skin comfortable, not tight.
- Glycerin: Non-irritating, plays well with almost every ingredient and suits all skin types.
- Vitamin E: Works well alongside other antioxidants to defend the skin.
16 ingredients
Caprylic/Capric Triglyceride, Olea Europaea (Olive) Fruit Oil, Glycerin, Aqua/Water, Sucrose Laurate, Caprylhydroxamic Acid, Aloe Barbadensis Leaf Juice, Camellia Sinensis Leaf Extract, Anthemis Nobilis Flower Extract, Calendula Officinalis Flower Extract, Vitis Vinifera (Grape) Seed Oil, Simmondsia Chinensis (Jojoba) Seed Oil, Tocopheryl Acetate, Propanediol, Caprylyl Glycol, Phenoxyethanol.
π Where It Fits in Your Routine
Use as the first step of an evening double cleanse to remove makeup and SPF, then follow with a water-based cleanser like The Matinee Cream Cleanser.
π How to Use
Apply to Dry Skin
Massage a generous amount thoroughly into dry skin to break down makeup, SPF, dirt and grime. Skip the water at this stage.
Emulsify or Wipe
Use a warm, wet washcloth to remove every trace of makeup, or add a little water to emulsify and then rinse.
Rinse Clean
Rinse fully with lukewarm water. Skin should feel hydrated and soft, never tight or stripped.
Double Cleanse (Optional)
For heavier makeup or PM routines, follow with a gentle water-based cleanser before serums and moisturizer.
π€ Who Is It For?
β Perfect for you if:
- You have sensitive, sensitized, dry or combination skin
- You wear makeup or SPF and want a gentle first cleanse
- You react to fragrance, essential oils or fruit acids
- You want a vegan, cruelty-free oil cleanser that won't strip
- You found the original fruit-acid After Show too active
β Consider alternatives if:
- You are managing fungal acne / Malassezia folliculitis
- You prefer a squeaky, matte foam-cleanser finish
- You want the lowest possible price per ounce
- You dislike using a cloth or a double-cleanse step
- You have a known coconut-derivative sensitivity
π― Skin Type Compatibility
Built for this: fragrance-free, no fruit acids, with soothing green tea, aloe and chamomile.
Nourishing oils and glycerin cleanse without stripping, leaving skin soft and hydrated.
Balances and comforts as a first cleanse; follow with a water-based cleanser if you get oily zones.
Works as a melt-away first cleanse, but very oily skin may prefer a lighter finish after double cleansing.
Brand calls it acne-safe and it rinses off, but the plant oils are not fungal-acne safe β patch test if prone.
π Results Timeline
Clean, Comfortable Skin
Makeup, SPF and grime melt away in one step, and skin feels soft and hydrated rather than tight.
~90% notice immediatelyCalmer Cleansing
Fragrance-free, acid-free formula tends to reduce the stinging or redness some users get from harsher cleansers.
~75% report less irritationSmoother, Less Reactive
With consistent gentle cleansing, sensitized skin often looks less inflamed and feels more balanced over time.
~65% see improvementβ Ratings by Platform
βοΈ Pros & Cons
β Praised
- Genuinely gentle and soothing on sensitive skin
- Removes heavy makeup and SPF without stripping
- Fragrance-free with no fruit acids or essential oils
- Vegan and Leaping Bunny cruelty-free
- Doesn't leave a greasy or tight after-feel
β Criticized
- Premium price compared with drugstore oil cleansers
- Not fungal-acne (Malassezia) safe
- Indie brand, so fewer mass-market reviews
- Requires a cloth or double cleanse for full removal
- Can sell out and require restock waiting
π° Budget-Friendly Alternatives (Dupes)
Gentle, fragrance-free balm-to-oil first cleanse for a fraction of the price. Smaller 50ml/150ml sizes and less of a soothing botanical blend, but excellent value.
Unscented, 95% naturally derived K-beauty oil cleanser with rice bran, jojoba and olive oils. Bigger 150ml size and very gentle, also not fungal-acne safe.
Lightweight centella-based cleansing oil at 200ml, soothing and affordable. Lighter texture and a less rich oil blend than the After Show.
π Comparison with Competitors
Jordan Samuel Skin After Show (Sensitive)
~$49The Ordinary Squalane Cleanser
~$9-20Haruharu Wonder Black Rice Cleansing Oil
~$20Peach & Lily Ginger Melt Oil Cleanser
~$32π¦ Storage & Shelf Life
Approximately 12 months after opening
Store in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight and heat
180ml squeeze tube (also in a 30ml / 1 fl oz travel size)
Yes β the 30ml travel size is well under the 100ml carry-on limit
β Frequently Asked Questions
It contains no retinoids, salicylic acid, hydroquinone or chemical UV filters β the ingredients usually flagged during pregnancy. As a fragrance-free, gentle rinse-off cleanser it is generally considered low-risk, but you should always confirm with your own OB-GYN or doctor before adding any product during pregnancy or breastfeeding.
No. It contains olive oil, grape seed oil, jojoba oil and sucrose laurate, which can feed Malassezia yeast. Because it is a rinse-off cleanser that doesn't sit on the skin, real-world risk is lower than a leave-on oil, but those actively managing fungal acne may want to choose a malassezia-safe cleanser instead.
Yes. As a first-step cleanser it is washed off before you apply any actives, so it doesn't interact with retinol, vitamin C, AHAs or BHAs. It's actually a soothing way to cleanse if those actives have left your skin a little sensitized.
It's formulated specifically for sensitive and sensitized skin, and also suits dry and combination skin very well. Oily and acne-prone skin can use it as a melt-away first cleanse, ideally followed by a water-based cleanser in a double-cleanse routine.
Cleansing results are immediate β makeup and SPF lift away on the first use and skin feels soft, not tight. Many users with reactive skin notice less stinging and redness within the first week, and a calmer, more balanced complexion over two to four weeks of consistent gentle cleansing.
It's the very first step of your PM routine. Massage it into dry skin to dissolve makeup and SPF, remove with a warm cloth or rinse, then follow with a water-based cleanser (optional), toner, serums and moisturizer.
It sits at roughly a 2 out of 5 on the comedogenic scale. The olive and grape seed oils rate a little higher individually, but because it is a rinse-off cleanser and built around lightweight Caprylic/Capric Triglyceride, most people don't find it pore-clogging. The brand markets it as acne-safe; patch test if you are very breakout-prone.
Around 12 months after opening. Store it in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight and use clean hands to keep the formula fresh.
Verdict: A standout gentle first cleanser for anyone whose skin reacts to fragrance, essential oils or fruit acids. The gel-to-oil formula melts away even heavy stage makeup and SPF without stripping, while green tea, aloe, chamomile and calendula keep sensitive and sensitized skin calm. It is a premium, indie price and not fungal-acne safe, but for dry-to-combination sensitive skin looking for a soothing, vegan, cruelty-free double-cleanse step, it earns its cult-favorite reputation.
Product Overview
What are Quick Product Notes?
Quick product notes are a great way to check if a product is free from commonly avoided ingredients by skincare enthusiasts. These preferences come about for different reasons depending on the ingredient such as personal experiences, sensitivities, health preferences & etc.
Pro Tip Alert!
Just because a product is not free from a common preference does not mean it's a bad product! You can make a personal decision whether or not you want to use a product that contains these ingredients or not - click the labels of the preference to read more about them.
Quick Product Notes
Paraben-Free
Paraben-Free
Understanding Parabens
Parabens are a large group of preservatives which are used to prevent bacteria growing in cosmetic formulations. There has been some healthy controversy surrounding them due to a few studies finding paraben presence in breast tumours and breast tissue. However, the majority of the scientific community have deemed these findings non-conclusive due to the limitations of these studies. There's still a lot of support for avoiding parabens following the better safe than sorry route. If you do we completely support you! If you are concerned about the health safety of parabens, then feel free to avoid them by looking out for the Paraben-Free icon. If not, don't worry about it - they do have had one of the longest safety records as preservatives!
Which Ingredients are classified as Paraben?
A product will be paraben-free if it does not contain any of the following parabens:
- Sodium Isobutylparaben
- Sodium Ethylparaben
- Sodium Butylparaben
- Propylparaben
- Isopropylparaben
- Isobutylparaben
- Sodium Propylparaben
- Butylparaben
- Ethylparaben
- Sodium Methylparaben
- Methylparaben
Sulfate-Free
Sulfate-Free
Understanding Sulfates
Sulfates are a large group of ingredients which act as cleansing agents in Cosmetics. They help loosen up the dirt and grime from your skin and hair to allow for water to wash it away with ease. However some sulfates are so good at their job, they can wash off your skinβs own natural oils that keep it moisturised and protected which can lead to dryness and irritation. Most people will find no issues with sulfate, however if you find your skin doesn't like sulfates then free feel to avoid them by looking out for the sulfate-free icon on Skincarisma.
Which ingredients are classified as sulfates?
We've taken the Sulfates which are considered more harsh for our Sulfate-Free status. A product will be Sulfate-Free if it does not contain any of the following Sulfates:
- TEA-Dodecylbenzenesulfonate
- Ammonium Laureth Sulfate
- Sodium Lauryl Sulfate
- PEG-15 Cocamine
- Sodium Laureth Sulfate
- Sodium Cocoyl Sarcosinate
- Sodium C14-16 Olefin Sulfonate
- Dioctyl Sodium Sulfosuccinate
- Ammonium Xylenesulfonate
- Ammonium Lauryl Sulfate
- Sodium Xylenesulfonate
- Sodium Myreth Sulfate
- Sodium Lauryl Sulfoacetate
Alcohol-Free
Alcohol-Free
Understanding Simple Alcohols
Alcohol ingredients are widely used in cosmetics and come in different types. For the most part alcohols are not problematic at all. However one type of alcohols, simple alcohols can be quite drying to the skin because it evaporates very quickly. This can cause irritation which can also lead to other skin complications. These alcohols should never be used alone on your skin, but combined with other cosmetic ingredients, they are normally without issue. However, for some people with sensitive and easily irritable skin, avoiding products with these simple alcohols may be beneficial. If you find your skin doesn't like these simple alcohols, then free feel to avoid them by looking out for the Alcohol-Free icon.
Which Ingredients are classified as Alcohol?
A product will be alcohol-free if it does not contain any of the following alcohol ingredients:
- SD Alcohol
- Alcohol Denat
- Isopropyl Alcohol
- Alcohol
Silicone-Free
Silicone-Free
Understanding Silicones
If you've ever used a skincare, makeup or beauty product that's made your skin look and feel smoother tempoarily - it's likely contained Silicone. They are a popular class of ingredients found in cosmetics due to their smooth, soft, easy-to-spread and smooth properties that help creates an artificial layer/barrier on top of skin or hair (commonly found in conditioners).
For the same reasons they are popularly used, they are also commonly avoided. Anecdotally, many individuals have reported that Silicones cause/excerbate breakouts, irritation, cause a feeling of skin being unable to breathe, cause clumping of cosmetic products and find it difficult to wash off. As a result, those who find them problematic are avoiding them and increasingly, cosmetic companies are avoiding them as well.
If you have had bad experiences with Silicones in the past, or suspect they are problematic then look out for the tick on the Silicone-free label.
Disclaimer
The Silicone-free label only includes the most common Silicone ingredients that have indentified been reported by individuals that could potentially cause issues.
These include: Amodimethicone, Behenoxy Dimethicone, Bis-Aminopropyl Dimethicone, Cetearyl Methicone, Cetyl Dimethicone, Cyclomethicone, Cyclopentasiloxane, Dimethicone, Dimethicone Copolyol, Dimethiconol, Methicone, Phenyl Trimethicone, Phenyl Trimethicone, Stearoxy Dimethicone, Stearyl Dimethicone, Trimethylsilylamodimethicone.
Note, that this does not include all ingredients part of the Silicone class of ingredients.
EU Allergen-Free
EU Allergen-Free
Understanding the Identified Contact Allergens
The EU's Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety (SCCS) has identified and established 26 cosmetic ingredients that are likely contact allergens (potential to cause skin allergies) as demonstrated in clinical or epidemiological studies. The EU's SCCS have recommend cosmetic companies to disclose them on the labels if used and in cases where the concentration exceeds 0.001% in leave-on products and 0.01% in rinse-off products, then they must be labelled.
Look out for the tick on the EU-Allergen free label to know your cosmetic is free from any of the 26 identified cosmetic ingredients.
For more information regarding the EU's Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety, please visit their official website.
Disclaimer
The EU Allergen Free label is for the 26 ingredients identified by the EU SCCS and products will be only flagged if a suspected ingredient is on it's ingredient list. It is possible for cosmetics to contain one of the suspect ingredients without it appearing on the ingredient list due to it not reaching the concentration threshold to disclose it and cosmetic manufacturers choice to not disclose it.
Also note, the EU Allergen Free label is not personalized for your own allergies you may have and it does not constitute as medical advice. For your specific case, always consult your medical professiona such as dermatologist, physician, pharmacist, or health care provider - please read our medical disclaimer for more information.
Fungal Acne (Molassezia) Safe
Fungal Acne (Molassezia) Safe
Understanding Fungal Acne (Pityrosporum Folliculitis/Malassezia Folliculitis)
Pityrosporum Folliculitis/Malassezia folliculitis or simply known as Fungal Acne is a persistent acne-like condition that commonly responds poorly to traditional acne-treating methods. Unlike most cases of Acne where bacteria is the culprit, Fungi is the culprit of Fungal Acne (Hence the name!). There are certain classes & groups of ingredients that have been shown to promote and feed the growth of the Fungal Acne, Fungi such as fatty acids, oils, esters, polysorbates and fermented ingredients.
For more information regarding Fungal Acne, please visit Simple Skincare Science (f.c) - #3 of our Recommend Skincare Resources for an amazing comprehensive guide!
Please Read: How to use the Fungal Acne (Malassezia) Label
At SkinCarisma, we've done our best to identify as many ingredients as possible but note the fungal-free label may not be 100% accurate due to the complexconditions and combination of ingredients that malezzeria can thrive on.
Additionally, products that may contain ingredients that have shown to feed Malassezia may not neccessarily exacerbate the condition due to concentration of ingredient used in the product, this information is simply not available on the products.
As a result, please note this is only an experimental label that can be best used to possible identify problematic products you have used in the past. It is in no way a perfect identifier nor a predictor in whether or not it will exacerbate or cause fungal acne. It will continue to be worked on as more information and research comes to light.
If you find any ingredients you believe should be included, please email us at snails@skincarisma.com.
Disclaimer
Due to the lack of substantial research into this area it is very likely there are other ingredients and class/groups of ingredients that could feed Fungal Acne which have not been indentified.
The Fungal-Safe label does not constitute as medical advice. For your specific case, always consult your medical professiona such as dermatologist, physician, pharmacist, or health care provider - please read our medical disclaimer for more information.
What are Notable Effects & Ingredients?
Ever used a product that promised a certain effect but provided no results? It might not have contained any notable ingredients that could have been responsible for that promised effect. It doesn't matter what the marketing or packaging Β«promisesΒ» it can do, if it doesn't contain anything that can help - then the likelihood of it helping is low.
We help you identify key notable ingredients that have been shown to help with effects such as acne-fighting, brightening, UV-protection, wound healing & anti-aging to help you achieve your skincare goals smarter. Please note that different notable ingredients have varying levels of research behind them, some are extremely well proven yet some have mixed research in their efficacy.
Pro Tip Alert!
Just because a product doesn't contain any notable ingredients doesn't mean it's bad. And a product with notable ingredients (or even many) doesn't necessarily guarantee the efficacy of the product performing these effects either. There are other factors such as ingredient quality, concentration and formulation that will ultimately determine this.
Be smart and use this as just a starting point for you to make more informed and smarter choices and compare it with reviews to see if the product is right for you
Notable Effects & Ingredients
Anti-Aging from 1 ingredient(s):
Brightening from 1 ingredient(s):
Promotes Wound Healing from 2 ingredient(s):
What are Ingredients Related to Skin Type?
Why are some products great for some people and horrible for others? Well everyone has different skin types and different reactions to the same ingredients.
We've identified a range of ingredients that are commonly regarded as potentially good or bad for those with Dry, Oily/Acne-Prone or Sensitive skin.
Pro Tip Alert!
A product that contains good or bad ingredients for your skin type doesn't always flat out make the entire product good or bad for your skin. There are other factors such as ingredient quality, concentration and formulation that will ultimately determine your skins reaction.
One of the best ways to use this section is to troubleshoot products you've had bad experiences with in the past. Check if it contains any of the marked ingredients to point out suspect ingredients to avoid in the future!
Ingredients Related to Skin Types
Dry Skin
Oily/Acne-Prone Skin
Sensitive Skin
What is the Ingredient Safety Breakdown?
Ingredient Safety Breakdown refers to the percentage % of ingredients in different risk categories as classified by EWG (Environment Working Group) if they are available. There are almost endless cosmetic ingredients and they are one of the few organisations globally that have assigned ratings to a lot of the more commonly used ingredients which is why we reference them.
Pro Tip Alert!
EWG is seen by many to be more on the alarmist side in their assignment of health ratings resulting in rating ingredients as riskier than they actually are. We recommend using this a reference point rather than a strict guide of ingredient safety and to always do further research if into ingredients that you may find suspect.
Ingredient Safety Breakdown
Product ingredient list
| EWG | CIR | Ingredient Name & Cosmetic Functions | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |
Caprylic/Capric Triglyceride
Solvent, Skin Conditioning, Masking, Perfuming, Emollient
|
|
|
| 0 |
Olea Europaea Fruit Oil
Masking, Perfuming, Skin Conditioning
|
Hydrating
|
|
| 2 |
Glycerin
Solvent, Perfuming, Fragrance, Humectant, Viscosity Decreasing Agent, Hair Conditioning, Skin Protecting, Denaturant, Skin Conditioning
|
Brightening
Promotes Wound Healing
Hydrating
|
|
| 1 |
Water
Solvent, Skin Conditioning
|
|
|
| 1 |
Sucrose Laurate
Skin Conditioning, Emollient, Surfactant, Emulsifying
|
|